Before They Sell: The Real Estate Tax Traps Seniors Fall Into — and How Smart Agents Can Protect Them
Helping agents understand the tax side of real estate.
“Seniors don’t lose money because they’re careless. They lose it because they trust whoever raises a hand to ‘help.’”
Every month, I meet elderly homeowners who are fixing bad tax returns — often because someone who meant well didn’t understand the rules.
The story is almost always the same:
A lifetime homeowner sells the family house.
The preparer misreports the sale.
A massive, avoidable tax bill shows up.
It’s not fraud — it’s bad guidance.
And for seniors, it can cost more than money — it costs peace of mind.
As Realtors, we can either close the deal or protect the legacy. The best do both.
The Hidden Tax Pitfalls for Senior Sellers
Here are the biggest mistakes I see, what causes them, and how you can spot the warning signs as a real estate professional.
1. Missing the Home Sale Exclusion
The rule:
Homeowners can exclude up to $250,000 (single) or $500,000 (married) of gain on the sale of their primary residence if they’ve lived there at least 2 of the last 5 years.
How seniors lose out:
They’ve moved into assisted living or rented out the home too long.
A surviving spouse misses the 2-year window to use the $500,000 exclusion.
The preparer marks the sale as an “investment property.”
Agent tip:
Ask early: “When did you last live in the home full-time?”
If it’s been more than three years, pause before listing and suggest a tax review.
2. Forgetting the Step-Up in Basis
The rule:
When a homeowner dies, their heirs receive a step-up in basis — meaning the home’s cost resets to its current market value.
If sold soon after, there’s little or no taxable gain.
How families lose out:
Titles were never updated after a spouse’s death.
Children sell too soon without verifying the step-up.
The property wasn’t in a living trust, forcing probate delays and confusion.
Agent tip:
Remind families that a simple trust can prevent future tax headaches and simplify title transfers.
3. No Record of Cost Basis
The rule:
Taxable gain = sale price − cost basis (purchase price + improvements).
How seniors lose out:
They’ve lost decades of receipts for remodels, additions, or repairs.
Their preparer “guesses.”
Improvements that should’ve raised basis — and reduced tax — go unclaimed.
Agent tip:
Add “Gather home improvement records” to your pre-listing checklist.
Every $10,000 in missed basis = roughly $1,500 in unnecessary tax.
4. Gifting Homes to Children Too Early
The rule:
When property is gifted, the recipient inherits the original basis — not the stepped-up basis they’d get if they inherited it at death.
How families lose out:
Parents “add kids to the deed” to avoid probate, triggering partial gift tax and losing the step-up.
When the kids sell, they owe tax on decades of appreciation.
Agent tip:
Always pause when title changes are discussed.
Say: “Before you record this, let’s have your tax or estate advisor review it.”
5. “DIY” or Pop-Up Tax Preparers
The problem:
Seniors often file with whoever offers to “help.” These preparers may be unlicensed, undertrained, or simply careless.
How it hurts:
Missed exclusions.
Misreported proceeds.
Double taxation on depreciation.
Missed senior tax credits or property exemptions.
Agent tip:
Keep a short referral list of EA- or CPA-level tax professionals who actually understand real estate.
How Realtors Can Step Up
You don’t have to be a tax expert — just the connector who cares enough to ask the right questions.
Here’s your framework:
Start the “Tax Talk” Early
Include tax planning in your pre-listing conversation:
“Before we decide on price or timing, have you reviewed the sale with your tax advisor?”
Encourage Trust and Estate Planning
A revocable living trust isn’t a luxury — it’s protection:
Avoids probate
Preserves step-up in basis
Prevents confusion for heirs
Keeps family wealth intact
Keep the Family Involved
When adult kids live out of state, miscommunication can ruin deals.
Invite them into the discussion early.
Build Your Senior Sale Team
Create a referral circle of:
Estate attorneys
Tax pros
Financial planners
You become the quarterback, not the technician.
The Bigger Picture
Seniors are trusting people — they come from an era when business ran on handshakes.
But today’s financial landscape punishes blind trust.
Every home sale involving an elderly client is more than a transaction — it’s a transfer of legacy.
The Realtor who slows down, asks questions, and connects clients to qualified professionals isn’t “overstepping.”
They’re doing what the industry should’ve been doing all along.
“Real estate isn’t just helping people move — it’s helping them transition safely.”
Subscribe to Commission Keeper — where Realtors learn how to talk taxes, trusts, and client care in plain English.
Disclaimer
For educational purposes only. Not legal or tax advice. Always consult a qualified professional before making financial or estate decisions.